Tuesday, January 20, 2015

Rough Stink Bugs

Rough stink bugs in the genus Brochymena, native to North America, have suffered ever since the arrival of the invasive Brown Marmorated Stink Bug from Eurasia. The two are easily confused at first glance, but if you find large numbers of stink bugs in or around your residence, chances are it is the invader, not our natives. Brochymena also overwinters in the adult stage, but usually stays outdoors, tucking itself under loose bark with other members of its kind, or finding some other snug place where conflict with people is minimal.

Last month I had occasion to go to Portland, Oregon, where I encountered the specimen shown above. It is likely Brochymena affinis, but identifying rough stink bugs to species is difficult if not impossible without scrutinizing the (dead) creature under a microscope.

Many times you will find Brochymena out and about on warm, sunny winter days. That does not mean they are easy to spot, however. They resemble both in appearance and texture the lichen-mottled bark on trees. Indeed, their other common name is "tree stink bugs." Adults fly well, and may alight on fences, the sidewalk, or some other similar, contrasting backdrop, and it is then that one usually recognizes them as animate objects.

Brochymena arborea, Manhattan, Kansas

Depending on which authority you consult, there are somewhere between 21 and 23 species of Brochymena found in North America north of Mexico. Adults of our species collectively range from 10-19 millimeters in body length, and are an overall gray color with black and white or ivory speckling. Eggs are laid in small clusters on twigs of trees, and the nymphs that hatch progress through four instars (an instar is the interval between molts) before reaching adulthood. Their development from egg to adult is surprisingly long, so there is but one generation produced annually, at least in temperate climates.

Young Brochymena nymph, Arizona
Fourth instar nymph, Texas

Their ability to withstand cold became abundantly clear to me when I was still collecting and preserving specimens. When I was in Cincinnati I discovered an aggregation of rough stink bugs beneath a shard of bark on a tree. I attempted to kill some of them by placing them in a container inside my freezer. I think I left them there about a week or so, took them out, and found them coming back to life in short order.

Rough stink bugs are not pests in any way, shape, or form, so consequently rather little is known about these insects of non-economic importance. They are suspected of feeding on the sap of host trees and shrubs, though there are persistent rumors that they are occasionally predatory. Since many true bugs (Hemiptera: Heteroptera) are opportunistic predators or scavengers on other insects, this may not be a stretch.

Brochymena sulcata? Colorado

So, how does one tell a harmless Brochymena from a pestiferous Brown Marmorated Stink Bug (BMSB)? First, look at the antennae. The BMSB has white bands on the last two antennal segments. Rough stink bugs have no such contrasting markings on the antennae. Second, look at the leading edge of the pronotum (top surface of thorax), right behind the head. There are fine teeth along that edge in Brochymena, not so in the BMSB.

Brochymena from Colorado: Note dark antennae, teeth on leading edge of thorax
Brown Marmorated Stink Bug: Note banded antennae, no teeth on front edge of thorax

Given their cryptic nature, it amazes me that any other creature could find them and make a meal out of them, but enemies they do have. Rough stink bugs are known to be the prey of the sand wasp Bicyrtes quadrifasciata, for example. The female wasp finds a stink bug, stings it into paralysis, and then flies it back to her nest burrow where she deposits it as food for her larval offspring. Birds, and fence lizards are also recorded as predators of the adult bugs. Feather-legged tachinid flies in the genus Trichopoda glue their eggs to the top of a stink bug's body where the insect cannot reach to groom them off. The fly larva that hatches bores through the exoskeleton of the host and feeds as an internal parasite, usually killing the bug eventually.

Brochymena quadripustulata, New Jersey

The eggs of Brochymena are also parasitized by the tiny platygastrid wasps Trissolcus brochymenae and Telenomus sp.; and the eupelmid wasp Anastatus reduvii.

Look for rough stink bugs in spring and fall when they are emerging from, and entering, hibernation. You'll have to look closely, though, given their camouflage.

Sources: Cuda, J.P. and J.E. McPherson. 1976. "Life History and Laboratory Rearing of Brochymena quadripustulata with Descriptions of Immature Stages and Additional Notes on Brochymena arborea (Hemiptera: Pentatomidae)," Ann. Ent. Soc. Amer. 69(5): 977-983.
McPherson, J.E. 1982. The Pentatomoidea (Hemiptera) of Northeastern North America with emphasis on the fauna of Illinois. Carbondale: Southern Illinois University Press. 240 pp.
Sutherland, Carol, and C. Scott Bundy. 2012. "Real Stinkers in Pecan Production: Stink Bugs, New & Old (plus Leaf-footed Plant Bugs)," Proceedings of the 46th Annual Conference of the Western Pecan Growers Association, pp. 44-55.

Brochymena sp., Colorado


  1. I may have seen one of these resting on my door over the weekend-- s/he was probably up and about because we had temps in the low 70s. They are pretty gnarly looking compared to the brown marmorated stink bugs! Love those serrations.

  2. We have had stink bugs in the house all winter. They must have come in on house plants I had outside this past summer. We were wondering what kind we have. Now I will have to capture one and look at it close. Thanks for this post.

  3. Once they invade your home how do you get rid of them?

    1. If they are invading in large numbers then they are not rough stink bugs, but Brown Marmorated Stink Bugs. Click on the blue "invader" word in the story above to get to that post.

  4. I have a rough stink bug in my kitchen right now. Lol I am going to let him go in my wood pile (where he came from).

  5. I'm laying in bed, and grab at something, I realize that I don't have anything there and promptly let it go. Turn on the lights and boom, it's bug. I do some digging cause I have no clue what it is, and find out it's a rough stink bug. It's missing it's 2 front legs, which may or may not have been from my initial grab, I have no way of telling. Just find it odd that it's in my room, or how the hell it got in here. I let it be for a short while cause why not, and it did nothing for a couple minutes, just sat there. It's not dead I can assure you that.


Blog author currently unable to reply to reader comments, nor comment himself. Working to resolve this.